When I was about fourteen I was dating an older boy who absolutely adored me. I told him I wanted a Ouija board so he tracked one down on eBay for me. I tried to play with it a few times and nothing ever happened.
One night I had some friends over and my sister, who's three years younger than I, also had some friends over. We lived on the farm and had this old grey round bin, it had a huge opening but no door and it faced the yard light and house. We used it for storage and a warm place for the cats to hide or sleep. Behind this bin was my dear dog, Foxy's, grave and then the corner of the horse pasture (usually where we'd called them to give them oats).
So there was five of us girls sitting around this Ouija board and candle, late at night and about a hundred yards from the house. We made a nice little circle and sat there with our hands on it, asking questions. I remember reading that if you see the flame flickering but the shadow of the candle doesn't move, something is there. I saw the flame was moving but the shadow wasn't and I pointed it out to the other girls. Everyone was already a bit jumpy just from using this Ouija board so watching the flame move but the shadow not, we got even more jumpy. We kept trying but it didn't move.
Suddenly we could hear what sounded like a stampede of horses running right behind the bin (past where the fence ended and we only had three horses, this sounded like a herd of them!). So I figured I'd walk around the bin and see if the horses were there. They were nowhere in site! All us girls kind of freaked out, grabbed the candle and board and ran to the house. A few of us were holding hands and I remember we were all so freaked out and not really paying attention, just trying to be the first to the house, that my sisters friend got clothes lined so we had to stop and pull her up.
A few days later my sister and I came home from school, my parents were both still at work. We came walking down the driveway, across the grass and up the steps. I kind of glanced around the yard because something seemed different. I noticed the horses were out and were eating oats off the ground in front of the oats bin. I glanced around the yard and it took me a minute to realize the round grey bin was gone! I walked over there to check it out and there were pieces of wood everywhere! Some pieces the size of a door were scattered and literally thrown through the horse fence. There were small pieces and slivers scattered around where the bin was, but the biggest pieces took out the corner of the horse fence.
My old man said plow wind but the bin was the only thing touched. The weirdest part of it all was that I walked around, looking at all this wood everywhere, trying to figure out how it could happen like that, and I noticed there was not a single sliver of wood on my dog's grave. It was like it was completely around, to the point it looked outlined. Still gives me shivers to this day.
I have a few more Ouija board stories but that one was the scariest.